Pakistan, a nation with a rich history and strategic geopolitical importance, has witnessed a concerning decline in its global law and order rankings over recent years. This decline not only impacts the country’s internal stability but also affects its international image, investment prospects, and overall socio-economic development.
In this article, we delve into the key reasons behind Pakistan’s fall in global law and order indices, explore the consequences of this decline, and suggest actionable steps to reverse the trend.
More Read: Sahiwal Tragedy: A Rot That Begins at the Roots
Understanding Law and Order Rankings
Law and order rankings typically assess countries based on various parameters such as crime rates, police efficiency, judicial effectiveness, political stability, and overall safety of citizens. These rankings are compiled by reputable organizations such as the World Justice Project, Numbeo’s Crime Index, and the Global Peace Index, among others. A higher ranking indicates better law enforcement, lower crime, and a more stable society.
Pakistan’s position in these indices has deteriorated significantly, which has raised alarms among policymakers, investors, and civil society alike.
Current Status of Pakistan in Global Law and Order Rankings
According to recent reports, Pakistan has dropped several places in global rankings related to law and order. For example:
- The Global Peace Index 2024 placed Pakistan at 153 out of 163 countries, indicating a high level of internal conflict and insecurity.
- The World Justice Project Rule of Law Index 2023 rated Pakistan low in areas such as criminal justice, corruption control, and fundamental rights.
- Numbeo’s Crime Index shows Pakistan experiencing an upward trend in crime rates, particularly in urban centers like Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad.
These rankings reflect a complex web of challenges facing Pakistan’s law enforcement and governance structures.
Key Factors Contributing to Pakistan’s Decline in Law and Order
1. Rising Crime Rates
Pakistan has witnessed an increase in violent crimes such as armed robberies, kidnappings, and sectarian violence. Urban areas, especially Karachi, have long battled with gang-related violence and ethnic clashes. The proliferation of firearms and drug trafficking exacerbates the problem, making it difficult for law enforcement agencies to maintain peace.
2. Terrorism and Extremism
The lingering threat of terrorism continues to disrupt peace in Pakistan. Despite significant counter-terrorism efforts, militant groups remain active, especially in border regions such as Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. Terrorist attacks have targeted civilians, security forces, and critical infrastructure, undermining public confidence in the state’s ability to maintain security.
3. Judicial Inefficiency and Corruption
A weak judiciary and widespread corruption hinder effective law enforcement. Delays in the legal process, low conviction rates, and lack of accountability have led to a culture of impunity. This diminishes public trust in the legal system and emboldens criminals.
4. Political Instability
Pakistan’s political landscape has been volatile, with frequent changes in government, military influence in civilian affairs, and political rivalries. This instability diverts focus from law and order priorities and often results in politicization of the police and security agencies.
5. Police Reforms and Capacity Issues
The police force in Pakistan faces issues of underfunding, inadequate training, and politicization. Many officers operate with limited resources and outdated equipment. Moreover, public perception of the police is often negative due to allegations of brutality, extortion, and inefficiency.
6. Socioeconomic Factors
High poverty rates, unemployment, and lack of education contribute to social unrest and criminal activities. Economic hardships push vulnerable populations toward crime, while social inequality fuels tensions between different ethnic and sectarian groups.
Impact of Pakistan’s Decline in Law and Order Rankings
Economic Consequences
A poor law and order situation directly affects Pakistan’s economy. Investor confidence is shaken by security concerns, deterring foreign direct investment (FDI). Tourism suffers as visitors perceive the country as unsafe. Local businesses face losses due to theft, extortion, and disruptions caused by violence.
Social Consequences
The deterioration of law and order undermines social cohesion. Fear and mistrust grow among communities, especially minorities targeted in sectarian violence. The youth face limited opportunities, with many drawn into criminal activities or extremist ideologies as alternatives.
International Reputation
Pakistan’s declining rankings harm its international standing. Countries view Pakistan as a risky partner for trade, investment, and diplomacy. This affects bilateral relationships and restricts Pakistan’s ability to project soft power globally.
Steps Pakistan Can Take to Improve Law and Order
1. Comprehensive Police Reform
Investing in police modernization is critical. This includes improved training, better salaries, adoption of technology such as body cameras and digital reporting, and establishing independent oversight bodies to reduce corruption.
2. Strengthening Judicial Processes
Reducing case backlogs and improving transparency in the judiciary will enhance justice delivery. Special fast-track courts for terrorism and violent crimes can ensure quicker resolutions and deterrence.
3. Enhanced Counterterrorism Measures
Continuing coordinated efforts among intelligence agencies, military, and police to dismantle terrorist networks is essential. Community engagement programs can prevent radicalization and promote peace.
4. Political Stability and Governance
Political parties must prioritize national security and law and order over partisan conflicts. Strengthening democratic institutions will ensure continuity in security policies and reduce politicization of law enforcement.
5. Socioeconomic Development
Addressing root causes such as poverty, unemployment, and education disparities will reduce incentives for crime. Programs targeting youth employment and social integration can foster resilience against extremist recruitment.
6. Public Awareness and Community Policing
Building trust between police and communities through community policing initiatives will encourage citizen cooperation and reduce crime rates.
Frequently Asked Question
Why has Pakistan dropped in global law and order rankings?
Pakistan’s decline is due to a combination of factors including rising crime rates, persistent terrorism threats, judicial inefficiencies, widespread corruption, and weak police infrastructure. Political instability and socioeconomic issues also contribute to the deteriorating security environment.
Which global indexes measure law and order rankings?
Key indexes include:
- Global Peace Index (by Institute for Economics and Peace)
- World Justice Project Rule of Law Index
- Numbeo Crime Index
These indexes evaluate countries based on safety, crime, police effectiveness, justice system performance, and public perception.
How does this decline affect ordinary citizens in Pakistan?
The impact is widespread:
- Reduced sense of safety
- Increased exposure to crime and violence
- Limited access to justice
- Diminished trust in law enforcement and institutions
It also discourages economic activity and foreign investment, indirectly affecting jobs and development.
Is terrorism still a major factor in Pakistan’s law and order issues?
Yes. While terrorism has declined from its peak in the early 2010s, militant groups remain active, especially in border provinces like Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. Sporadic attacks on civilians, security forces, and infrastructure continue to undermine national security.
What is the role of the judiciary in this decline?
Pakistan’s judiciary is often criticized for:
- Delayed case processing
- Low conviction rates
- Susceptibility to political and elite influence
These issues allow criminals to act with impunity and erode public trust in the legal system.
What reforms are needed to improve Pakistan’s law and order situation?
Key reforms include:
- Police modernization and depoliticization
- Strengthening judicial independence and efficiency
- Improved intelligence and counterterrorism coordination
- Socioeconomic upliftment to address root causes of crime
- Community-based policing and public trust-building
Can Pakistan recover its standing in these global rankings?
Yes, but it requires sustained and coordinated efforts from all levels of government, civil society, and security agencies. Long-term commitment to transparency, justice, and inclusive development is essential for improving both internal stability and international perception.
Conclusion
Pakistan’s fall in global law and order rankings is a multifaceted problem rooted in social, political, and institutional weaknesses. Reversing this trend demands a comprehensive approach combining security reforms, judicial improvements, political stability, and socioeconomic development. Improving law and order is not just a matter of ranking but a critical step toward ensuring peace, prosperity, and progress for Pakistan. With sustained commitment and strategic action, Pakistan can restore its image as a secure and stable country, attracting investment and safeguarding the well-being of its citizens.
